- Colts are much better made and more precisely fitted, of finer and stronger materials, than Smith & Wessons. I base this statement on the personally observed differences in working internal parts with a diamond file, and wear and peening in contact surfaces with comparable round counts.
- The Smith & Wesson single stage lockup is not nearly as precise as, but much more durable than, the Colt double stage lockup. The Smith & Wesson bolt is softer but less stressed than the Colt bolt. The S&W action is much easier to work on than the Colt action.
- The Manurhin MR73 is a significantly improved S&W K-frame Combat Magnum derivative that combines the quality and precision of the Colts with the ruggedness of the Smith & Wessons, and ease of tuning unavailable in any other service revolver.
The problem with S&W is not design, but quality. Their basic action layout is capable of uncompromising performance, as witness this Manurhin chambered in .32 S&W Long, beating match guns by S&W, SAKO, and Walther. But in order to get a current production S&W to perform like that, you would have to rebarrel it and replace its MIM lockwork with increasingly unobtainable forged parts. And even then, it will not approach the quality of Manurhin's hammer-forged frame, barrel, and cylinder.
The basic features of Colt double action revolvers are well summarized by Grant Cunningham:
|Colt revolvers have actions which are very refined. Their operating surfaces are very small, and are precisely adjusted to make the guns work properly. Setting them up properly is not a job for someone who isn't intimately familiar with their workings, and the gunsmith who works on them had better be accustomed to working at narrow tolerances, on small parts, under magnification.|
Since you are in Norway, the Manurhin MR73 makes more sense than either the Colt Python or any S&W. It is as strong as a Ruger, as lively and easy to work on as a K-frame S&W, and much smoother and more precise than either of them. You can find them with barrels measuring 2½", 3", 4", 5¼", 6", 8", 9", and 10¾", though 4" and 6" are the most common variants. Some of my current and incoming revolvers are shown here. The 6" target model is nimble enough to be used for self-defense, while its sight radius is adequate for target shooting. I get my Manurhins on Egun.de for a fraction of the new retail price. Many of the sellers can be talked into exporting, but if you have a problem getting them to ship to Norway, contact me via email for assistance.